How Did We Get Here? And Where Are We?
We haven't ever been here before. The debt landscape has changed dramatically and irrevocably, and the ways in which we borrowed, spent, and repaid debts before are relics of the past.
The cash-back credit card offers that used to crowd our mail-boxes have dried up.
There's no such thing as a "No down payment? No problem!" mortgage.
Those tempting teaser rates are long gone, replaced by "gotcha" interest costs so high you'd think the Mob was involved.
It's sometimes impossible to borrow money at any price -- for college, a car, or a home renovation. And you need to submit a credit card at the front desk before a doctor will even see you now.
It may seem like credit has dried up altogether, just when you need it the most.
What hasn't disappeared is the debt. American consumers are on the hook for close to $3 trillion, not counting their mortgages, according to the Federal Reserve. The average credit card holder is juggling almost $11,000 in debt on close to 13 cards. Roughly one of every three homeowners is underwater, meaning that they owe more on their homes than the homes are worth.
And paybacks are rough. As banks and other lenders began pulling back on credit, they tightened terms and squeezed indebted consumers. Interest rates skyrocketed, and so did minimum monthly payments on everything from credit cards to mortgages.
Middle-class people who were barely making it aren't making it anymore. Those in the worst situations are trapped in houses they can't afford to pay for and are unable to sell. Others are selling homes at bargain-basement prices and downsizing. Or sending their kids to community colleges instead of the private colleges they were aiming for. Or working nights and weekends and skipping lunch to make the payments on their MasterCard and Visa bills.
And yet, all is far from lost. If there were no good news, there would be no reason for this book. I'd just crawl back into bed and call it a day -- or a decade.
But there is good news. In the first place, the dialing back of debt in the United States was necessary. As a society, we got overextended. Now, there's a renewed feeling of responsibility in the air as banks and consumers ratchet back to a more sustainable and stable way of doing business. The federal government has stepped in, over and over again, to tighten standards of behavior for creditors and to protect the borrowing public. There are more ways to protect your home, your family, and your credit score than there were a year or two ago.
And, as has always happened in U.S. economic history, the marketplace is adapting to the new era with new products and services for consumers. Some of them are shoddy, or worse. But many offer new and innovative ways to manage debt.
That's why we're here. With the right information and the right techniques, you can take charge of your debts, blow them away, and prosper. You can negotiate with your credit card issuer, rework your mortgage, and improve your credit score so you qualify for the lowest-cost, best deals out there.
You can pay off your mortgage years -- and thousands of dollars -- early. You can still find credit card issuers that pay you back. You can get more cash out of your child's first-choice school that you don't have to pay back.
I will show you how.
But first, it's instructive to see how we got here.
A Long Time Coming
Americans have had a long love affair with debt, but it really rose to prominence in the 1980s and 1990s. The deregulation of financial institutions meant that there were many more lenders competing for borrowers and that they faced fewer rules about their interest rates and practices.
More debt became securitized -- bundled up and resold to investors. Mortgage-backed securities were the most common of these arrangements, and they resulted in mortgage-backed mutual funds for investors and a big, steady stream of cash for mortgage lenders. As everything from auto loans to credit cards got securitized, that meant more money coming back to banks and other issuers so they could quickly turn around and lend it to new borrowers. This also served to separate the lenders from the ultimate holders of the debt: Banks that issued mortgages weren't holding on to them; they were selling them off as fast as they could issue them.
At the same time, the credit scoring business was growing up. This gave lenders quick numerical answers to their questions about the creditworthiness of customers. Instead of poring over credit reports for hours, they could get a score in moments that would qualify a borrower as a good prospect.
Here's what happened when all of that came together: Lenders that issued mortgages, car loans, student loans, and even credit card accounts were able to make money fast by qualifying a borrower, collecting a fee (or, more typically, a lot of fees), and then selling the loan off to someone else. The lenders didn't even really care whether the borrower made good on the loan; they only cared about the borrower looking good enough to qualify in the first place.
As interest rates fell in the 1990s, refinancing became another popular way for lenders to make money, over and over again, from the same homeowners. They encouraged people to do cash-out refinance deals -- borrow against the swelling equity in their homes to pay off other debts, improve their homes, send their kids to college, and do anything else that struck their fancy.
By 2005, the country was in the midst of a housing bubble, and would-be homeowners were told they should do whatever it took to buy a house before it was too late and they couldn't afford it any more. Some lenders simply allowed themselves to be pressured by brokers, real estate agents, homeowners, and their own bosses to make more and more loans. But some particularly unethical predatory lenders went out of their way to push cash-out refinance deals on unqualified, unsuspecting, and naive (often elderly) homeowners who gave up good, small, inexpensive loans for subprime deals that turned out to be disasters.
The creative folks in the mortgage and real estate industries did what they could to invent new mortgages that would allow more and more borrowers to qualify. There were new mortgages that required no down payment and no demonstrable income from borrowers. They started with teaser rates, tiny monthly payments and a feeling of euphoria. But they held deadly traps, like interest rates that reset at levels that doubled and tripled monthly payments, and amortization schedules calculated so that the balance of the loans grew over time instead of shrinking.
While that was happening, everything from college to cars was becoming less and less affordable. College costs were rising precipitously, and neither household income nor government aid programs were growing quite as fast. Lenders rushed into that void, too -- creating a student loan industry that was predatory in its own way. At its worst, it was found to be kicking money back to schools that were recommending costly private loans to students who had been told that no price was too high for a good education. Those loans carried an implicit college seal of approval that made students and their parents think they were good deals.
As cars became unaffordable, dealers and manufacturers cooked up auto loans that stretched longer than the useful lives of the sport utility vehicles they were paying for. It became possible to get a seven-year car loan, and it was not unusual for car owners to trade in their cars before their loans were paid off. They were adding the balances of their old loans to their new car loans.
Credit cards became as common as head colds, and issuers who could now qualify borrowers and process payments for pennies went crazy promoting the cards. Every store and affinity group, from sports clubs to hamburger joints, had its own card. To encourage consumers to use the cards for even the tiniest pack-of-gum type purchases, issuers started promoting the cards with big cash-back bonuses for money charged at gas stations, convenience stores, and groceries. Then they started piling on the fees. Issuers that used to depend on interest income and fees from merchants discovered they could really cash in if they charged consumers for being late, for going over their credit limits, for getting cash advances, and for anything else they could think of.
Borrowers did their part, buying into more and more debt for any and every reason, and thinking it was all okay. By 2006, the United States had a negative savings rate for the entire year. That means -- and it bears repeating -- that as a nation, on average, all Americans were spending more than they made, borrowing to make up the difference. Consumer debt quintupled between 1980 and 2001, and then practically doubled again to $2.6 trillion in 2008.
Pop! It had to happen. The credit spree that had taken decades to build came to a crashing halt in 2007. It started when the lowest tier of mortgage borrowers -- those folks who'd been talked into crazy mortgages -- stopped being able to keep up with the rising monthly payments. The investors who held big portfolios of weak loans didn't have the cash to ï¬‚oat new loans. The bankers stopped making money. Housing prices started to fall, and people weren't able to refinance, pull money out of their homes, or even get new loans for new homes. Prices fell further. The banks, worried about where the next shoe was going to drop, started pulling back on consumer debt. They cut credit lines on home equity lines and on credit cards. Consumers lost their borrowing ability and their breathing room. Stocks got slammed, and it all started spiraling downward. Joblessness, bankruptcies, delinquencies, and interest rates were on the rise, and spirits, paychecks, and economic activity dropped.
The government stepped in, on almost a dozen different occasions. In the fall of 2007, President George W. Bush created the Hope Now Alliance, a union of mortgage investors (including giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac), the Federal Housing Administration, mortgage lenders, and trade groups. The group was to provide free counseling and voluntary workout assistance to troubled borrowers. In September 2007, Congress passed, and President Bush signed, the College Cost Reduction and Access Act, which cut interest rates on federal college loans and eased repayment options for struggling graduates.
Early in 2008, Congress enacted the Economic Stimulus Act of 2008, legislation that put an additional $600 into the hands of most taxpayers quickly. That wasn't enough, though, to address the systemic problems that worsened throughout the year. In July 2008, under President Bush, Congress passed the Housing and Economic Recovery Act of 2008, designed to ease credit in the mortgage markets and make more cash available to support refinance loans for sub-prime borrowers. The Higher Education Opportunity Act was passed by Congress and signed by President Bush in the summer of 2008. In February 2009, President Barack Obama and Congress approved the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009. This was a grab bag of provisions, including money for students, car buyers, and homeowners. In March 2009, the Obama administration unveiled a comprehensive mortgage relief plan called "Making Home Affordable." In subsequent months, it refined and amended that program. Later in 2009, Congress passed, and President Obama signed, a comprehensive credit card reform bill.
For a more detailed account of how credit became a worldwide obsession that took control of our lives and what can be done, by you and by the government, to help regain our independence from the heavy burden of debt, you must read Master Your Debt by Jordan E. Goodman with Bill Westrom.